Debate, and discuss, just dont Bore me.
They have hit bottom and started to dig
Published on August 1, 2005 By Dr Guy In Current Events

In another show of callous disregard to the human race or anything approaching humanity, PETA has a new Ad Campaign against people.  Except this time they really have gone too far!  Instead of enobling their cause, which I am sure was their aim, they just demonstrate how callous and inhumane they are.

In the latest Ad campaign, they are equating selling breeding cattle and horses to the horror of the slave trade 200 years ago!  They are not enobling their cause, they are cheapening the plight of the blacks of that age!  And that is just plain sickening!

If there was any shred of humanity or compassion in those clowns before, it is apparent that they have none now.  It is too bad that they take what is arguably one of the most tragic times in American history and belittling it by comparing it to the selling of Cattle!

They are beneath contempt!  They do not deserve even the effort for spitting on them, for that would be to acknowledge them as contemptable, and that is too good for those creeps.


Comments (Page 11)
13 PagesFirst 9 10 11 12 13 
on Aug 14, 2005

Not really, i'm an exception, not the rule. I even eat my steaks rare so they won't go down like nasty fibrous planty flesh...

Well, that does make 2 of us!

on Aug 16, 2005
Yes but Draginol, here you are just imposing your beliefs on everyone and expecting them to agree with you without you backing up your point. I understand that many people believe animals aren't sentient, but there is a lot of evidence to suggest you may be wrong, and PETA is equally justified in believing the opposite of what you do.


I doubt anyone's following this thread anymore, but I'll respond to a topic I sorta raised. I think what PETA was arguably disrespectful, but no I wouldn't call it mocking per se. As to the disrespect, it is only disrespect if you see it from your viewpoint instead of theirs:

You see that PETA is likening blacks to animals (because you believe that humans are superior)
PETA sees that they are likening animals to blacks (and all other humans because they believe animals and humans are equal).

The subtle difference is important. If you start from PETA's belief that animals are equal to humans, then you would have to say that maltreatment of animals is equal to maltreatment of humans. An example of maltreatment of animals is possibly slaughterhouses, and an example of maltreatment of humans was black slavery. To them, saying that particular people are like animals is not insulting, because they don't believe that being an animal makes you inferior. You may not agree with their belief, but if you want to look past their poor tact, the ad is not as insulting as it seems at first glance.

For this reason I don't agree that the abortion comparison is spurious. Whether abortion is ethical or not revolves around what you believe about the foetus and whtether it is considered a proper, living being. Whether you believe eating meat is ethical or not depends on whether you believe that an animal is a proper living being. I don't believe abortion is murder, but I'm not insulted by the assertion, and I think it's the only logical position for an anti-abortionist. I do believe that meat is murder, but I don't point it out to people, because I have more tact than PETA. (I also happen to believe that killing animals for meat is acceptable in some circumstances. But certainly not in the quantities that Western cultures eat meat in today. That is only a very recent phenomenon, and I don't agree with it. But, I digress, we were talking about PETA's beliefs, not mine.)

PETA's desire to end meat eating may not be realistic, but the world would never get anywhere if we didn't have idealists. Who knows, one day their ideals may be considered normal.

Drmiler, did it ever occur to you that those cookbooks of yours might have been tailored to Western tastes? I can assure you I have a much easier time of it in Asia than I do out here, even when I eat in an Asian restaurant.
on Aug 16, 2005

You see that PETA is likening blacks to animals (because you believe that humans are superior)
PETA sees that they are likening animals to blacks (and all other humans because they believe animals and humans are equal).

So I can keep a lampshade made from Jews from Auschwitz since I dont see them as human, right?  That is what you are saying.  I wonder how many friends I would have with that kind of attitude. There is no PETA viewpoint here that is defensible.  Period.

on Aug 16, 2005

Non-sentient life shouldn't have rights.

Who is the last word on what is sentient?  We used to say just humans were, but now they say dolphins and whales are.  The basic definition of sentient is: "choice-making consciousness" (latin: "to feel").  Dogs, by the basic definition, would be sentient.  Even the bible says that both animals and humans are "living souls" ("nefesh chaya") .....Now, "sapient" could be a better argument

meat provides essential nutrients. you can get it from Chicken, pork and even sea food. And SOME veggies.

I think that you need to study food nutrients a bit more.  ALL veggies have protein in them.  Ever look at the food nutrients in legumes?  What about rice? (which is an asian staple for a reason) Compare your meat nutrients with a serving of brown rice and broccoli.

Even if we couldn't live without meat, what is the reason that we process it in the fashion that we do?

on Aug 16, 2005
Taking them away from their mom early, raising them in tiny little houses, and making them anemic to make their meat tender.....yeah, I see how that is ethical. They don't even have a chance to live at all.


Just caught this. "Make" them anemic? Do you even know what they feed a vealer?
on Aug 16, 2005
I think that you need to study food nutrients a bit more. ALL veggies have protein in them. Ever look at the food nutrients in legumes? What about rice? (which is an asian staple for a reason) Compare your meat nutrients with a serving of brown rice and broccoli.


What exactly are the figures? No site I have been able to find will give the protein figures in brown rice and broccoli. I was able to find the info on meat however. Single serving....protein runs between 25-30 grams depending on whether it beef, pork or veal.
Link
on Aug 16, 2005
I take that back. Here's the one for brown rice:

Brown Rice/1 cup cooked

Calories 217
Total fat (g) 1.8
Saturated fat (g) 0.4
Monounsaturated fat (g) 0.6
Polyunsaturated fat (g) 0.6
Dietary fiber (g) 3.5
Protein (g) 5
Carbohydrate (g) 45
Cholesterol (mg) 0
Sodium (mg) 10
Niacin (mg) 3
Vitamin B6 (mg) 0.3
Manganese (mg) 1.8
Magnesium (mg) 84
Phosphorus (mg) 162
Selenium (mcg) 19



Healing Kitchen Links


Also found the broccoli


Broccoli/1 cup cooked

Calories 44
Total fat (g) 0.5
Saturated fat (g) 0.1
Monounsaturated fat (g) 0
Polyunsaturated fat (g) 0.3
Dietary fiber (g) 4.5
Protein (g) 5
Carbohydrate (g) 8
Sodium (mg) 41
Beta-carotene (mg) 1.3
Vitamin C (mg) 116
Vitamin E (mg) 2.6
Folate (mcg) 78
Manganese (mg) 0.3
Potassium (mg) 456



Venison 34g 6.5g 200
Veal fillet (roast) 30g 12g 240
Goose (roast) 30g 25g 350
Pheasant (roast) 30g 9g 250
Partridge (roast) 29g 8g 250
Pork Chops (grilled) 28g 24g 340
Turkey (roast) 28g 6g 165
Corned beef canned 27g 12g 220
Rabbit 27g 8g 187
Pork Leg (roast) 27g 20g 290
Chicken Calories (average) 26g 12g 140
Lamb Leg (roast) 25g 17g 270
Bacon Calories (average rashers) 23g 45g 500
Beef Calories (average lean) 25g 20g 275
first number is protein in grams


So using these figures that would be 10 grams total per serving in the veggie department as opposed to 25-30 grams for meat. "You" do the math!
on Aug 18, 2005

I think that you need to study food nutrients a bit more. ALL veggies have protein in them. Ever look at the food nutrients in legumes? What about rice? (which is an asian staple for a reason) Compare your meat nutrients with a serving of brown rice and broccoli.

SOME Veggies have the necessary complex protein that can replace meat.  That is why some people can be Vegans.  But that does not mean that all veggies have the necessary proteins, and hence why many areas cannot support a vegan lifestyle.

on Aug 18, 2005

Just caught this. "Make" them anemic? Do you even know what they feed a vealer?

Mostly milk (hence the milky white appearance).  And the reason I dont eat Veal.

I like Meat, but I can still object to the way it is prepared and not eat that which I dont find kosher by my standards.

on Aug 18, 2005

 

SOME Veggies have the necessary complex protein that can replace meat. That is why some people can be Vegans.

You combine plant proteins to make complete proteins (which is the example of rice and broccoli, which together provide all 9 essential amino acids).  Also, don't confuse vegans with vegetarians, they are not the same.  At no time have I proposed anyone eat a vegan diet.  To me, eggs seem like one of the most logical, natural, food sources (back to my theory of what you can get with your own two hands).

So using these figures that would be 10 grams total per serving in the veggie department as opposed to 25-30 grams for meat. "You" do the math!

*nutrients*, drmiller, I said nutrients, not just protein.  How much protein do we *need* in a day?  An average is 55 to 66 grams (55 being a person in their ideal weight category).  So, the rice and broccoli supply about 1/6th of your entire day of protein *plus* a vast amount of nutrients not found in meat.  Meat also averages around 20grams of fat per serving (whatever your serving size was from that chart...which I can assume is 3 oz which is the recommended serving size) whereas the rice and broccoli is less than 3, of which only .5 is saturated.  You can't live on meat alone (well, not for very long, at least) but you can live on veggies.

The amount needed shows how Americans eat *way* too much meat.  Say you ate a 6 oz steak, a serving of broccoli, a serving of rice and 2 eggs in a day (we'll ignore everything else because it just adds to it).  What does that add up to? Over 70grams, which is more than anyone needs.  And, I think it's a safe bet that the average person eats way more than that in a day.


Just caught this. "Make" them anemic? Do you even know what they feed a vealer?

Unless you are talking about the milkers, which aren't even weaned from their Moms before they are slaughtered (yeah, that sounds ethical), yeah, they are made anemic by not being allowed to eat grains and grass when they are at the age that they need to.  Instead, they are continued to be fed "formula" and kept in a veal house away from pasture.  I've always lived in farm country, so I'm not oblivious to how things really work on farms.

on Aug 19, 2005
I'm sorry Dr Guy, I don't follow your analogy.

But to have a stab at what I think you are talking about (and I may be way off here, cos I just need it explained a little more), the difference again is that the Nazis had a viewpoint that was saying that Jews are worthless, as in they claimed Jewish people were worth less than what everybody else thought they were worth. PETA has not actually claimed that black people are worthless: they still believe that black people are important (just as much as you and I do), but they also believe that animals are equal to us (and ergo to black people). What's wrong with that?

Arguing against that would have been like KKK members in the last Century saying "you can't say that mistreating blacks is the same as mistreating whites. That's demeaning to white people". When in actual fact, when people first started saying that black people were equal to white people, there was no demeaning of white people involved, just a more high valuing of black people. As it turned out, they were proved right.
on Aug 19, 2005

You combine plant proteins to make complete proteins (which is the example of rice and broccoli, which together provide all 9 essential amino acids). Also, don't confuse vegans with vegetarians, they are not the same. At no time have I proposed anyone eat a vegan diet. To me, eggs seem like one of the most logical, natural, food sources (back to my theory of what you can get with your own two hands).

I use the term Vegans as a short term way of saying vegetarians.  And some of the foods that are required for a vegetarian diet are not available in all parts of the world.  That is my contention.  Not tha they could not be, but due to growing conditions, economics and politics, they are not.

on Aug 19, 2005

Reply By: Champas Socialist

Last I checked, man could not interbreed with animals.  There is no question they are different.  But blacks and whites are not different except in the pigmentation of their skin.  Which if you take that even farther, most blacks are different from each other as are most whites.  Very few have identical pigmentation.  So your analogy fails there.  But what PETA is trying to do, is not to raise animals up, for there is a clear difference in both biology and psychology, but to demean and cheapen a tragedy that man visited upon itself.  They are cheapening it by using it, and no amount of spin is going to change that.  They can screw their dogs if they want to, but that is not going to make the dogs people, no matter how long they try to.

on Aug 19, 2005

I use the term Vegans as a short term way of saying vegetarians.

Vegans and Vegetarians are different, though.  Vegan is a real term for Vegetarians that don't eat *any* animal protein (eggs and dairy).  Vegetarians do- they don't eat meat (and some don't eat eggs)

on Aug 19, 2005

Vegans and Vegetarians are different, though. Vegan is a real term for Vegetarians that don't eat *any* animal protein (eggs and dairy). Vegetarians do- they don't eat meat (and some don't eat eggs)

I stand corrected and will try to be more careful in my use of the terms in the future.

13 PagesFirst 9 10 11 12 13