Debate, and discuss, just dont Bore me.

As has been noted before, wackiness in the court room is not restricted to the US.  Indeed, the first "right to non-life" suit was filed in Australia.  Now comes more good news from Australia.  An Affirmative action case filed for "Over Promotion"!  That is right!  The first black body guard for one of the Royals (Camilla Parker-Bowles), Sgt Leslie Turner sued and won for being promoted too fast, not receiving enough training, making mistakes, and then being reassigned!

I think it is very Ironic, and I am glad he won!  While I think he should have been given the opportunity to succeed at his chosen profession, it appears that some pencil necks were only interested in making his occupation, more rainbow oriented, without regard to qualifications.  Had they done it right, it might have taken Turner a few more years to achieve the pinnacle of his profession, but as he correctly pointed out in his lawsuit, he would have been better prepared and trained for it when he did achieve it.

My Only question now, is Ruth Ginsberg going to use the Precedent when a minority student sues Harvard for accepting him/her, even though they were not as qualified as other students, and thus flunked out?  While no law suits have been brought yet, cases of students ill prepared for the rigors of some of the Ivy League schools flunking out have already been documented.


Comments
on Jan 11, 2006
No, Doc, since as Alito said yesterday, we should not look to foreign courts to set precedent under the American judicial system. We should not even look to them for understanding or insight.
on Jan 11, 2006
Praise the Lord and Pass the Ammunition!!

In Milwaukee, Art Jones was the Chief of Police for awhile. He was a total loser who got every promotion because of lawyers. It will take the city 30 years or more to work out the fruits of his lack of experience, judgement or common sense.

Now that he's "retired" (read fired with full benefits), his latest lawsuit is against the department he headed... for all the "discrimination".

Winners will succeed, but there's nothing like a crafty loser, with a good lawyer to feign success. ;~D
on Jan 11, 2006
Now that he's "retired" (read fired with full benefits), his latest lawsuit is against the department he headed... for all the "discrimination".

That is balls. You know what would be delicious irony? If in the investigation, they discover his having been propped up by the system, and take back all his pay & bennies.
on Jan 11, 2006

No, Doc, since as Alito said yesterday, we should not look to foreign courts to set precedent under the American judicial system. We should not even look to them for understanding or insight.

Counterpoint:  But Ruth Buzzi (see Stute?  I avoided it until the comments) and Stephen Breyer have stated we must look to foriegn courts for precedents when ours fail us in that regard!

on Jan 11, 2006

In Milwaukee, Art Jones was the Chief of Police for awhile. He was a total loser who got every promotion because of lawyers. It will take the city 30 years or more to work out the fruits of his lack of experience, judgement or common sense.

We had one like that.  Andre Parker!

But then Doug Wilder hired a tough no nonsense guy from where?  Macon Georgia!  OMG!  He is a Bigot right?  Not hardly!  Rodney Monroe is black, bad and worked his way up!  And the fact we nabbed that bacteria responsible for 7 (some say many more) deaths in 7 days is due to him and his ideas!

And do you know that the "touchy feely" people were yelling when Richmond Hired him?

He Smokes!

TS!  He is getting the Job done you jerks!

on Jan 11, 2006

That is balls. You know what would be delicious irony? If in the investigation, they discover his having been propped up by the system, and take back all his pay & bennies.

Well, then he can just sue like Turner did! (altho I think Turner has a real case).

on Jan 11, 2006
That is balls. You know what would be delicious irony? If in the investigation, they discover his having been propped up by the system, and take back all his pay & bennies.


Unfortunately, the retirement scam in Milwaukee County government has NO provisions for revoking bennies. He could go to prison for the rest of his life for murder and rape, and still get full benefits.
on Jan 11, 2006

He could go to prison for the rest of his life for murder and rape, and still get full benefits.

Unfortunately, here as well!

on Jan 12, 2006
No, Doc, since as Alito said yesterday, we should not look to foreign courts to set precedent under the American judicial system. We should not even look to them for understanding or insight.

Counterpoint: But Ruth Buzzi (see Stute? I avoided it until the comments) and Stephen Breyer have stated we must look to foriegn courts for precedents when ours fail us in that regard!


I want to see an episode of "Supreme Court SMACKDOWN!"
on Jan 12, 2006

I want to see an episode of "Supreme Court SMACKDOWN!"

Shame Gilda is gone.  She would have made a great Ruth Buzzi with her Emily Latella role!