Debate, and discuss, just dont Bore me.
Is being created today
Published on April 22, 2005 By Dr Guy In Current Events

Several JU users have blogged on culture lately, each with their own point to make.  The latest was Australian, who reveled in the fact that they literally have their token black and asian and are thus a great culture.  Dont get me wrong, I admire and respect the Australian culture as being one of the best in the world today.  But it is not the best.

That being said, if we are going to micro-slice every nationality into its own subculture (with some degree of justification), then Australia still falls a very poor second (if that) to the US.  For in reality, while both countries were originally settled by the English and both countries paracticed Genocide on the Natives of the land from the time of the settlement until the 19th century (America) or 20th century (Australia), what happened in the dash is the rest of the story.

For in Australia, non-english immigration is a new thing.  For once America booted the English out (Australia never did, they allowed you some autonomy), we had waves of immigrations from all over Europe, Asia and even Africa.  These waves of immigaration made it so that less than 25% of the US population can claim to even be 50% English by heritage.  I dare say the statistics in Australia is a lot higher.

But of all those 200 cultures that came in and created the US, almost all have bought into the predominant American Culture and blended in without losing their identity.

But they have shed some of the worst parts of their own culture in becoming Americans.  Those that practiced hate against another culture for the simple reason they were different may try to maintain that in the US, but by 3rd generation, it dies out.

So Australia can celebrate your very limited diversity, but with such an overwelming majority from one culture, you really have no conception of cultural diversity and how it affects every day life in your country.  This is not to say it is a bad thing, just a fact of life as you are probably more diverse than 95% of the nations on this planet.  Yet, by far the most diverse is the United States, and we have used that diversity to make us the strongest and most powerful.

With exceptions too few to enumerate, every person of every culture who has flocked to these shores is proud to be an American, and celebrates both their nation and their culture, in peace.

Australia is a very young country and has a lot of growing up to do.  I wish you well.  But in the arena of cultural diversity, you are yet a toddler to the US's adult. It would be well for you to study how the US dealt with it.  Its many mistakes, and its many successes.

For in the end, the mixing of eggs, flower, sugar and chocalate has not made a gooey inedible mess, but the greatest culture on the face of the planet.  A culture of Mankind, that is greater than the sum of its parts, and is a shining beacon for all humanity to follow.  Jealousy does not become the old powers of europe whose policies are just short of xenophobia when it comes to outsiders.  There is a sprinkling of other races, colors, creeds, but Europe is as lilly white today as a Klan meeting.

Africa is not so discriminatory, with some excpetions (Zimbabwe and Sudan come to mind).  Yet, they are third world, and so there is not a lot of in migration as they cannot support the native population.

South America is a great example of what to do when new immigrants mix with natives (not a perfect one, but the best one this planet has to offer).  And it is much more diverse than the old worlds and Africa due to the liberal (cultural, not political) acceptance of all people, including Europeans.

Asia is an anachronism.  So racially pure for the most part, and intollerant of infusion, that they make old Europe look liberal in its efforts to remain pure.  Yet they are changing, if ever so slowly.  Perhaps that is why they fell so far behind Europe, but that is for another blog.

Alone among the continents and nations, however, is North America.  Not due to a grand scheme, but due to luck more than anything.  America offered and still offers a chance to break out of feudal systems and layer of royalty the stiffle the old world.  So the best of the underclass left their homeland, and fought, toiled and made something they could not be back there.  They made themselves sucessful Americans.

But nothing is without pain, and the assimilation of the different cultures has not been easy or error free.  And that is why, not only Australia, but all countries should heed the errors made.  But the lesson is not to stop the assimilation of the cultures, but to facillitate it.  That does not mean subverting the old culture, but taking the best parts and celebrating it as part of the new Culture.

For American culture is just that.  Not English, not European, not any single or double culture or land.  it is the cake that came from the different ingredients.  And as such, closer to a culture of humankind than any other on earth.

And it is the best for that reason as well.  It is not perfect, but it is the best and getting better.

It ill behooves the other nations of the world to condemn what some of their own people have created.  It simply demonstrates their own pettiness and jealousy of that they have no understanding or comprehension of.

It is not the Ugly American that walks the earth.  It is a Proud American!  One who is European, African, Asian, and American.  Proud because they have done what no other country in the history of this planet has done, and in a shorter time.

And they will continue to do.  For while we are spat upon and reviled in the old staid countries, we are building the future with hope and promise for ANYONE, not some one born with a red mark on their forehead, or a silver spoon in their mouth.

And we are not selfish with this thing we created.  But then we are also not imperialistic with it either.  Other countries of the world may accept it, may adopt it, or not.  It is their choice.

But I would again suggest that at the very least they learn from it.  Hate is easy.  Everyone can hate that which they do not understand.  It is the intelligent person tho that attempts to learn from others mistakes as well as their own.

That is what America can do for you.  But we cannot make you learn.  You can lead a horse to water, but you cannot make him drink.

Hate us, or love us.  But if nothing else, learn from us.  We are not perfect, but we are the best on earth.  If you think that is arrogant, fine.  Learn from our mistakes and be better than us.  There can be more than one winner in this race.


Comments
on Apr 22, 2005

illegals who refuse assimilation

But see, that is where you are wrong.  For in the end, they are assimilated.  It is only the actions of do gooders that attempt to stop it that makes it seem they are not.  In the end, they add the best of their culture to the batter to make the best culture anywhere on the planet.

Our traditions may be short, but that is because we are a young nation.  WHo borrowed (or assimilated) almost every cultural icon we have, and we will continue to borrow or assimilate into the future.  For we are not one race or nationality (other than american) and so it is difficult for any one to smother the others as it is in Europe and Asia and as it is being practiced in Australia.

You cannot legislate a culture.  it grows from the beliefs and practices of the citizens.  You can retard it by trying to control it, but then you just get the subculture (not like the subculture of the 60s) that will eventually surface and become mainstream once the thought police are gone.

on Apr 23, 2005
Good article Doc. I of course disagree with you about the USA being the best. Australia is, and that is partly because of our diversity.

I think that both Australia and the USA have unfortunately overlooked many of the greatest things we could borrow from other nations as we have both expected immigrants to become Anglo-American or Anglo-Australian to too great a degree, and still do.

"Your little island might be a paradise on earth at the moment"

But see, it's not. We still have plenty of people here who complain that our immigrants (be they onshore or offshore applicants) refuse assimilation, suck up services, avoid taxes, drive local hospitals into bankruptcy, force school districts to employ bi-lingual teachers, fill our prisons and send most of the wages they've earned back to Asia to help the rest of their damn family sneak over the border. If we are so lacking in diversity, then why do we have so many people with just as strong grievances as LW?

The percentages may be different, but currently it seems many Australians are trying to learn from America: they read people like LW and they take on board the lesson that multiculturalism and multiracialism can't work and it must be stopped.

I on the other hand think there needs to be more effort made to encourage immigrants to openly declare and be proud of their cultural backgrounds. When you simply ignore it, they learn to become ashamed of it. I mean, what is it about their culture that we're so scared they're going to bring to Australia?
on Apr 24, 2005

I think that both Australia and the USA have unfortunately overlooked many of the greatest things we could borrow from other nations as we have both expected immigrants to become Anglo-American or Anglo-Australian to too great a degree, and still do.

You see that is my exact point in opposite.  Your culture is Anglo, ours started out that way, but due to the overwelming immigration of so many other cultures, the only thing that remains of the Anglo here (for the most part) is the language (and even then you hear the English claim we dont speak it, as I am sure they do with you).

Indeed, part of the reason that the anglo part in America is so subsumed in the greater American Culture is due to the fact that we had to rebel, and in so doing, we then went to the other extreme and tried to stamp it out.  Is it any wonder that our monetary system is based upon the Spanish Dollar, and not the English Pound?

America is a culture formed by immigration and assimilation of many cultures.  And those that come and try to maintain their own distinct culture only suceed for a few generations before the best of theirs is assimilated into the American culture.  We dont erradicate it, we use the best of it and make it our own.

on Apr 24, 2005

The percentages may be different, but currently it seems many Australians are trying to learn from America: they read people like LW and they take on board the lesson that multiculturalism and multiracialism can't work and it must be stopped.

In a free society that does not place restrictions on its members (and even in one that is not totally free), it cannot.  It can only be legislated.  It cannot exist in the real world.  For every distinct culture that comes into a society will borrow from that society, and society will borrow from it, until neither is distinguishable, with minor trapping exceptions, for the other.

on Apr 24, 2005

I on the other hand think there needs to be more effort made to encourage immigrants to openly declare and be proud of their cultural backgrounds. When you simply ignore it, they learn to become ashamed of it. I mean, what is it about their culture that we're so scared they're going to bring to Australia?

And that is exactly right!  IN America, no one denies that to any immigrant.  It is truly a laissez faire form of culture assimilation.  If their's is better in some way, it gets assimilated into the greater culture, and the parts that are not as good, dont.  And eventually, the new immigrants (2nd or 3rd generation) accept the new culture.  it is just the do gooders with no understanding that try to stop it, and they only delay it.