Debate, and discuss, just dont Bore me.

Aw, there it is again!  The Big but.  This time it is none other than that senile congressman from Pennsylvania, John Murtha.  In it, he is accusing some US troops of murder.  But doing so in a way that not only impugns the troops under investigation, but all the troops.  In his own words:

"there was no firefight, there was no IED (improvised explosive device) that killed these innocent people. Our troops overreacted because of the pressure on them, and they killed innocent civilians in cold blood."

Hmmm.  On the one hand he is saying the troops overreacted because of the pressure on them.  That happens.  Whenever there is fighting with troops, there is the chance of overreacting.  Sometimes, you cannot tell a friendly from an enemy.  It happens in all wars.  It is one of the dirty sides of war and why it should be avoided whenever possible. 

But then he goes on to say "in cold blood".  Websters defines that phrase as follows:

Deliberately, coldly, and dispassionately.

So what is it Murtha?  Did the pressure get to them and they over reacted?  Or did they methodically plan to kill a bunch of civilians.  Looking for the right opportunity to go on a blood fest?

It is not bad enough that these marines committed a crime.  That has yet to be proved, but the Military has indicated the facts point to that scenario.  No, Murtha must impugn the troops by saying they cannot handle the pressure, but that they are still capable of cold premeditated murder.

With support like that, it is a wonder that not all the troops have cracked under the pressure.  Maybe Murtha and his ilk should stop supporting the troops so there would not be as much pressure on them.  Then the accidents would stop.


Comments (Page 1)
2 Pages1 2 
on May 19, 2006

It sounds to me like he's trying to cover his you know what! 

That old "but" is interesting,  I love how some people use it not realizing that they've just given themselves away....

some people use it intentionally,  to try to throw others off.  However they'll mess up in other areas.

on May 19, 2006
I wonder if he includes his colleague from Massachusetts in his disgust for servicemembers who commit war crimes. At least we KNOW Kerry commited attrocities, while what these troops did is still being investigated. Also, do the people of the 12th District realize that Rep. Murtha was speaking for them when he said this? Do they realize that their voice in Washington DC just used it to trash their brothers and sisters, fathers and mothers serving in Iraq? I wonder if the men of the 1/107 Field Artillery Rgt know that their representative in Washington think that they aren't up for the task?
on May 19, 2006

It sounds to me like he's trying to cover his you know what!

No, he has gone off the reservation.  He no longer realizes what he is saying, just saying what his handlers want him to.

on May 19, 2006

Also, do the people of the 12th District realize that Rep. Murtha was speaking for them when he said this? Do they realize that their voice in Washington DC just used it to trash their brothers and sisters, fathers and mothers serving in Iraq? I wonder if the men of the 1/107 Field Artillery Rgt know that their representative in Washington think that they aren't up for the task?

I wonder if his people realize it.  He probably got to Washington because of his military record. But now like the clueless old liberal Klink, all he can do is trash those who, for the most part, are serving with honor and distinction.

on May 19, 2006
It happens, I finally am ashamed of a marine!
on May 19, 2006
It happens, I finally am ashamed of a marine!


Nooooo!

on May 19, 2006

It happens, I finally am ashamed of a marine!

Your post is the nirvana. "A Marine".  Not THE Marines.  Not THE Troops.  A MARINE.  Murtha should be as good as you.

on May 19, 2006

Nooooo!

Read it again, carefully.

on May 19, 2006
John Murtha is a senile old goat who probably listens more closely to his (liberal) staff than he reads the info briefs he gets.

Don't worry; he regularly gets skewered on "Quinn and Rose in the Morning", a Pittsburgh-based conservative news/talk show. Awesome show; Jim Quinn is the Man. Not a complete Bushbot like Rush, either.
It's on 104.7 for those in the area, and also on XM Radio channel 165 for those who have it, from 6-10.
Now that they're on XM, the views of local folks commenting on the Murtha issue can be heard across the country. Most callers don't think much of him.
on May 19, 2006
Democrats and their "Culture of Treason".
on May 19, 2006
I tried to edit my post above, but it wouldn't let me.

If anyone is interested, Quinn and Rose's webiste is at:

www.warroom.com
on May 19, 2006
Read it again, carefully.


I understood it. Even *A* marine is, "AAAAAHHHHH!" (Sorry, I just have a wee bit pride in my grandfather and his father, and brother having been marines...call it silly if ya will)

~L
on May 19, 2006
Here, Doc; I just came up with this:

"John Murtha's (revised) Marine Corps Hymn"---Words By Rightwinger


"From the fall of the Twin Tow-ers,
to the Ir-aq-i Ass-embley....

We should help our country's at-ta-ackers
on the air, in print and TV!

First to make the Amer-i-can folks feel bad,
then to blame it all on Bush!

And to root for the terr-or-ists to win,
'Cause free-dom don't deserve the puuuush!"



on May 20, 2006

John Murtha is a senile old goat who probably listens more closely to his (liberal) staff than he reads the info briefs he gets.

You are probably right on in that analysis.  As for the radio show, We cant get it down here in the old Dominion.  Are the streaming?

on May 20, 2006

Reply By: Island DogPosted: Friday, May 19, 2006
Democrats and their "Culture of Treason".

ANd corruption!  They got it all over the amature republicans.

2 Pages1 2