Debate, and discuss, just dont Bore me.
Published on March 16, 2006 By Dr Guy In Entertainment

For a change, the Academy Awards were not another Political side show with actors and actress barely able to articulate their names without queue cards bashing everyone who did not believe that their every utterance was an epiphany.  Or so it seemed at the time.

But there was another battle going on.  That of Brokeback Mountain.  And while some raved about it and said how ground breaking and deep it was, most people yawned and went about their lives.  And on Oscars night, many gays, in anticipation of a 'Gay' film winning an academy award (it actually won 3, just not Best Picture), had Brokeback parties.  But alas like Philadelphia before it (that was actually nominated for more Awards than Brokeback), it did not take home the top banana, so some were disappointed.

I can understand that.  Hey, we all make sporting events out of our favorite contests, no matter what it is.  And there is no question that Crash (which was called a Race movie, but that is like calling Gone With the Wind a southern movie) is an outstanding movie that is actually entertaining and does teach you a valuable lesson to boot.  It just plain was a great movie.  There is no shame is losing to a great movie.

Until now apparently.  The writer of the short story (not even a novel), Annie Proulx, has decided that Hollywood must be filled with a bunch of Homophobes and gay bashers for that movie to have lost.  She actually goes on to write:

Academy members who vote for the year's best film are "out of touch not only with the shifting larger culture and the yeasty ferment that is America these days, but also out of touch with their own segregated city,"

Out of touch?  While Gay bashing and homophobia may be a problem, it is in no way the whole of society's problems, nor should it be the sole focus of our attempts to make society better!  This tin plated pip squeak has a lot of nerve, and not a lot of talent!  She could have accepted the fact that her pitiful little story got as much play as it did and been proud of that, but instead she has to go and slam the entire movie industry (I never thought I would be defending them!), and by extension, all of American society.

I have a message for you Ms. Proulx.  Take your short story and shove it where the sun dont shine!  And then go put on a burka, because your beloved enlightened France is going to be Muslim soon enough, and then they will burn that story.  And probably you with it.

Jerk.


Comments
on Mar 16, 2006
Things like this just piss me off. I have zero respect for people who try to demonize every little action. A movie didn't win best picture, the world must be ending.

Morons.
on Mar 16, 2006

people who try to demonize every little action

This is even worse as she is doing it out of selfishness, and not any altruistic reason.

on Mar 16, 2006
~~Academy members who vote for the year's best film are "out of touch not only with the shifting larger culture and the yeasty ferment that is America these days, but also out of touch with their own segregated city,"~~


Wow...and here I thought the Academy was IN touch for giving the award to a movie that deals with modern racial issues...

Crash was a really good movie...I enjoyed it. It opens your eyes to things that some people don't want to open their eyes to. I'm actually glad it won (It makes me wonder...did this man even SEE Crash or know what it's about?).

As for Brokeback, I'm sure it's a good movie, too (I'd like to see it sometime), but I just don't think there's any use "crying over spilled milk" just because it didn't win.
on Mar 16, 2006
Crash was a really good movie...I enjoyed it. It opens your eyes to things that some people don't want to open their eyes to. I'm actually glad it won (It makes me wonder...did this man even SEE Crash or know what it's about?).

As for Brokeback, I'm sure it's a good movie, too (I'd like to see it sometime), but I just don't think there's any use "crying over spilled milk" just because it didn't win.


Exactly! Crash was a great movie. SOmetimes there is more than one and like you, I never saw Brokeback, but I did seecrash!
on Mar 16, 2006
"Academy members who vote for the year's best film are "out of touch not only with the shifting larger culture and the yeasty ferment that is America these days, but also out of touch with their own segregated city,"


mmm, yep. Gay cowboys are the pulse of our culture. As far as 'relevance', I'd say 200 years of adjusting to the equality of black Americans has, oh, maybe a TAD of relevance. No doubt the kind of 'change' in our attitudes touched on by brokeback is a big deal now , but gay cowboys are a sideshow, just like flaming gay people dragging straight people around teaching them how to dress.
on Mar 16, 2006
cannot say I was dissapointed by brokedick mountain losing.
on Mar 16, 2006
I haven't seen it, nor do I want to see it. It seems to me that this writer was somehow counting on this PC bit of drivel providing a gravy train and is just pissed off because it wasn't quit as long a train as she counted on.
on Mar 17, 2006
Crash WAS the best movie last year. While I haven't seen 'Brokeback Mountain' and I'm sure it was well made, shot great, well-written and very well acted, but if it wasn't for it's gay storyline would it have gotten the a majority of the critic awards nationwide? If it was a love between a man and a woman the movie could have been as good as everyone says it is but would the critics and media have push it for awards?

btw ... some Los Angelinos are complaining about Crash winning. They say the only reason Crash won is because most of the voters are from Los Angeles. They wish Crash lost since the movie shows their city in a bad light, and no way does it show the real Los Angeles.
on Mar 17, 2006

As far as 'relevance', I'd say 200 years of adjusting to the equality of black Americans has, oh, maybe a TAD of relevance.

But that was the beauty of Crash!  It was not Black vs White, it was Vietnamese vs Hispanic, Black vs Chinese, and yes, some black vs white.  It was about all races, and the good and the bad side of all of them.

on Mar 17, 2006

cannot say I was dissapointed by brokedick mountain losing.

I really did not care.  But that prunes comment just set me off.

on Mar 17, 2006

It seems to me that this writer was somehow counting on this PC bit of drivel providing a gravy train and is just pissed off because it wasn't quit as long a train as she counted on.

Yep!  So it seems she did not write a good short story, she wrote an editorial, and expected us to kow tow to her!

on Mar 17, 2006

They wish Crash lost since the movie shows their city in a bad light, and no way does it show the real Los Angeles

It could have been any city!  That was the beauty of it.