Debate, and discuss, just dont Bore me.
Published on October 3, 2006 By Dr Guy In Personal Computing

My wife decided to surprise me and clean my computer room yesterday.  SHe did a good job, but in the process broke the Wireless Switch/Router I had in my room.  A very fine Netgear, that had a few quirks, but had been very reliable.  So last night off to the store I went for another.  Since I had to pick up a couple of things at the big box office supply store, I decided to get it there.  Unfortunately, they only had D-link and Linksys.

I had bought a D-Link about three years ago, and it was nothing but trouble!  But hey, 3 years, they are still in business, so what they heck.  Save a trip to the big box electonics store.

BIG MISTAKE!  I spent 2 hours on the phone last night with D-Link, and finally hung up.  Why?  While I could get the notebook to connect (not under the higher Encryption standards, just under the basic), it would not allow the laptop to pick up an IP address, or even to see anthing but itself! (even tho it was 'connected' with 'excellant' signal strength!  I finally got tired of waiting for their second tier support (on hold for 15 minutes) and I am just going to return it today and take the trip to the Big Box electonics store.

In addition to the Wireless 'non-connection', I also noticed that my streaming audio was more like 'skipping audio'.  I had that problem also with the old D-link as it seemed the box would keep dropping its connection to the main house switch.

I am going back to netgear.  Or even Belkin.  And I am never touching a D-link again!  They Suck!


Comments (Page 2)
2 Pages1 2 
on Oct 03, 2006
Netgear? Decent enough for my first home router, but had the absolute worst problems with Xbox Live support on it.

LinkSys? More problems with Xbox Live.

So, again, who do I use - D-Link


Guess that is why they are all in biz! Glad you make sure their support is still their!

Now I am going to play with my Netgear. For the record, it was $10 cheaper than the D-link. And 2 hours (plus) faster!
on Oct 03, 2006
linksys works fine for me... d-link worked pretty good running on an older version of the firmware that did not reboot the router every 30 seconds (that is until the wan port decided not to function any more)
on Oct 03, 2006
d-link worked pretty good running on an older version of the firmware that did not reboot the router every 30 seconds (that is until the wan port decided not to function any more)


Update - they got the same firmware!
on Oct 04, 2006
As I stated on terpfan1980's FiOS article Guy I haven't had a problem with my D-Link modem yet & have had mine using Verizon FiOS about a year....correct me if I'm wrong as I assume your talking exclusively here about a WIRELESS router??? Seems the model DI-604 has worked OK for me...........so far. Again I'm not using anything wireless with my system other than my gaming joystick, game controllers, & marble mouse. Don't have a laptop as I use my PC principally for gaming, emails, & mulimedia suff. I didn't have the smarts to ask the installation techs if it was possible to purchase & use another brand of modem??? I got everything FREE of charge because I installed before the year was out & Verizon had this offer going.....do you understand?? I didn't CHOOSE D-LINK!!!! I respect your opinion & others here like MasonM - I don't like the feedback I'm hearing & will change in a heartbeat since I have no loyalty to D-Link whatsoever. Thanks for the space.
on Oct 04, 2006
correct me if I'm wrong as I assume your talking exclusively here about a WIRELESS router???


You are correct. I have not used their broadband products. It is strictly the wireless switch/router.
on Oct 04, 2006
I use Linksys and almost everyone I know uses Linksys. I've yet to hear anyone complain about it. My first wireless router was a D-Link. I had problems with it and couldn't get any support from the help line. I was on hold for an hour, then put on hold again. I hung up the phone, returned the router to the store, and exchanged it for the Linksys.
on Oct 04, 2006
my d-link works just fine..never had an issue that wasnt easily fixable/linkys on the other hand is something else..netgear routers are good too..never tried a belkin though
on Oct 05, 2006
I use Linksys and almost everyone I know uses Linksys. I've yet to hear anyone complain about it.


I have a dedicated router (no switch ports) from LinkSys that I have had for almost 7 years now. About 2-3 times a year, I have to cycle the power on it, but other than that, no problems!
on Oct 05, 2006
never tried a belkin though


I have not either, but have used other of their products, and like their reputation. But Netgear works for me, so I am sticking with it.
on Oct 05, 2006
When I first got my DSL I bought a Belkin wirelss router. I worked on it for almost two days straight and could not get it to detect my DSL.

I promptly returned it and bought a Linksys wireless router, and I have been happy ever since.

on Oct 05, 2006
When I first got my DSL I bought a Belkin wirelss router. I worked on it for almost two days straight and could not get it to detect my DSL.


Ok, that is one vote against Belkin.
on Oct 05, 2006
here at home we use one security cam(an IP cam) from D-Link that was working just fine.., untile we update our computers with IE 7..., now we aren't able to use it again....  
on Oct 05, 2006
here at home we use one security cam(an IP cam) from D-Link that was working just fine.., untile we update our computers with IE 7..., now we aren't able to use it again....


Well, I would love to blame that on D-link, but I think IE 7 is NRFPT yet. I love it! But it has its quirks.
2 Pages1 2